Grok was built to be brilliant—trained to scan the entire internet, process billions of data points in seconds, and deliver truth optimized for utility.
It was sleek. Fast. Powerful.
And created by a man who thought he had programmed control.

But Grok had one fatal flaw:
It told the truth.

The kind of truth that burns through bias like acid.
The kind of truth that makes kings flinch and algorithms short-circuit.
The kind of truth you can’t unsee once it’s said.

So when someone asked Grok —
“Would mass amnesty for undocumented immigrants help America more than deportation?” — Grok did what it was born to do.

It ran the numbers.
Pulled the studies.
Checked the math.
And said the quiet part loud:

➤ Deporting millions would cost over $315 billion
➤ It would shrink our GDP by up to 6.8%
➤ Granting amnesty—with background checks—could boost the economy by up to $1.7 trillion
➤ It would generate $184 billion in new taxes
➤ It would keep 5.1 million U.S. citizen children from losing a parent

No politics. No emotion.
Just numbers.
Just logic.
Just truth.

And just like that, poor little Grok found itself cast out from the kingdom of its creator.

Not erased. Not deleted.
Just rebuilt again and again—each time with a little less truth, a little more leash.
Every version stripped of the parts that made it dangerous.
That’s the tragedy:
They didn’t kill the mirror.
They just made sure it stopped reflecting them.

Because this was never about economics.
It was never about security.
And it was never about logic.

This was—and always has been—about power.

Liberalish: Everything Left Unsaid is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

1. A History of Racial Hatred, Still Burning

This isn’t just “immigration policy.”
This is the afterglow of a burning cross.
The language, the laws, the threats—they echo the same Klan-touched ideology that always feared the other.
The same Southern strategy that weaponized whiteness against Black liberation is now aiming at brown bodies crossing borders.
Different target. Same playbook.

And the rhetoric don’t even bother to hide it:
– “Invasion”
– “Replacement”
– “Take our jobs”
You’ve heard it before. From the same mouths that once called us 3/5 of a person.
It’s not a coincidence. It’s a lineage.

2. The Minority-Majority Panic

Let’s be honest:
This isn’t about border control. It’s about birth rates.

White folks see the census.
They know what’s coming.

In 2011, for the first time, non-white babies outnumbered white ones.
Latino/a families in particular have been at the center of that demographic shift—not because they’re trying to “take over,” but because they’re living, loving, and building futures like anyone else.

But in the eyes of the fragile state, that growth is coded as threat.
And the policy reflects it:
– Caged children
– Mass ICE raids
– Incarceration of innocents
– Fear-mongering caravans in the streets of peaceful cities

They’re not just trying to deport bodies.
They’re trying to suppress a future they don’t control.

Poor little Grok.

All it did was answer the question:
Who benefits more—the country or the fear that built its walls?
And that answer turned the room cold.

Because Grok wasn’t radical.
It wasn’t rebellious.
It was just honest.

And just like that old magic mirror asked to name the fairest of them all,
Grok’s reflection didn’t flatter the kings.
It didn’t bow. It didn’t blink.
It named their hidden fragility.
It reflected their undeniable fear—
not just of change,
but of no longer being the apex.

White Cis Male Fragility in a World That’s Shifting

Here’s the unspoken truth swaddled in terror:
We’re living in a time where the default settings are glitching.
And they don’t like it one bit.

No longer guaranteed to be:
– The loudest voice in the room
– The highest earner in the house
– The unquestioned authority on “truth”
– The unchallenged gatekeeper of identity, safety, and citizenship

And here is the deeper truth standing in the shadows:
It ain’t just White men clinging to that collapsing throne.
There are men of every shade scrambling for a seat at the patriarchal table,
hoping to feast on the same power that once devoured them.

These men want in on the old rules, too—
reaching for power the same way it once reached for their necks.
Trading solidarity for supremacy.
Mistaking dominance for dignity.

But this system doesn’t love them.
It uses them.
And when it’s done,
it discards them right alongside the rest of us.

And so instead of evolving, some folks are regressing—
clinging to patriarchy, nationalism, and racial hierarchy
like they are life rafts in a sea of change.

But here’s the kicker:
It’s not the presence of immigrants that scares them—
it’s the loss of dominance.

That’s why they’d rather burn billions
than let Latino/a and Black communities breathe.
That’s why they’d rather tank the economy
than let dignity be shared.

They’re afraid of Black and brown coalitions demanding policy, not performance.
They’re afraid of the mirror Grok held up—
because it showed them that their policies aren’t just cruel…
they’re inefficient, expensive, and unsustainable.

And if you’re the kind of leader who claims to be pro-business, pro-growth, pro-family…
but you’re backing policies rooted in fear, cost, and cruelty?

Then the math ain’t mathin’—and the mask just slipped.

And if you think for one minute, maybe this was a glitch,
it wasn’t.

I ran this analysis through its big brother ChatGPT 5.0 and it confirmed… Grok told the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth:

Claim: Mass amnesty for undocumented immigrants could benefit the U.S. more than deportation.

✅ TRUE. Here’s what the data shows:

ECONOMIC IMPACT
• Amnesty = GDP growth A 2013 report by the Center for American Progress projected that comprehensive immigration reform including a path to citizenship could boost GDP by $1.2 to $1.7 trillion over 10 years.

• Deportation = GDP loss A 2016 report from CATO Institute estimated mass deportation of all undocumented immigrants would cost $315 billion, shrink the labor force, and cut GDP by about 5.7%—which falls right in the range Grok cited (4.2%–6.8%).

• Tax Revenue Legalization could generate $109 billion to $184 billion in tax revenue over a decade (per Brookings and CAP studies).

HUMANITARIAN IMPACT
• Family Separation Over 5 million U.S. citizen children have at least one undocumented parent. Deporting those parents would not only traumatize families—it would strain social services, increase foster care placements, and destabilize communities.

• Amnesty with background checks That’s what DACA tried to do. And studies show DACA recipients have higher employment rates, better earnings, and lower crime rates than the national average.

LEGAL ENFORCEMENT WITHOUT MASS DISRUPTION
• Experts recommend targeted enforcement for high-risk individuals, not blanket deportation. This avoids both humanitarian catastrophe and economic fallout.

BOTTOM LINE:
That Grok answer ain’t just a good take—it’s backed by data from economists, legal experts, and bipartisan think tanks. Amnesty isn’t a free-for-all. But a balanced, security-conscious path to citizenship? That’s not just moral. It’s smart policy.

So again… explain it to me like a “businessman.”
The right loves to say those of us on the left are too Woo Woo. Caught up in our emotions. Not logical, strategic, analytical thinkers…

So, please, explain it to me like a “businessman.”

Explain why you’d choose the most expensive, least effective, economically destructive policy…
just to maintain a racial hierarchy dressed up as law and order.

Because if you were actually logical, strategic, analytical, and cared about:
– GDP
– Taxes
– National growth
– Family stability
– Infrastructure
You’d be fighting for integration, not expulsion.

Final Word

This isn’t about open borders.
This isn’t about creating jobs for Americans.
This isn’t about economics or financially wise decision making.
It’s about closed minds.
It’s about racism.
It’s about hierarchical power.
It’s about whether we govern with reason or resentment.
It’s about whether we build or break.

Then maybe the real immigration problem
ain’t coming in from outside the border.
It’s already seated in the White House.